You Do Not Have to LeaveChapter 6 of 145 min
The temple, if you have one
What follows is not what I expected to find when I went looking, and I have left it as it came back rather than as it was meant to come back. It is less convenient and more useful.
Two readers, two different fears
If you have an observance — a temple, a church, a mosque, a set of festivals, a thing your mother does that you do beside her — your fear is losing it. You suspect that going any distance into this would end with you explaining to somebody who loves you why you have stopped, and that the explanation would be unbearable for both of you.
If you have none, your fear is the opposite. You suspect there is an entry rite. Something you are expected to believe before you are allowed in, some first act of belonging, probably involving a word you would feel ridiculous saying.
The second fear is easier to deal with, so let me do it now. There is no entry rite. Nothing is required of you before you start, there is nothing to sign, no declaration, and no first act. That is simply true and it is the end of that paragraph.
The first fear needs a longer and less comfortable answer.
The uncomfortable part, said plainly
I could tell you that nothing changes here and you would believe me, because it is what everybody says and because it is what you would like to hear.
It is not what the material says.
The material's own view is that devotional practice belongs to a stage, and that people who go far into it leave it behind — and it says so without embarrassment, in passing, as a settled thing. It describes its own people looking back at bells and beads and finding that they belong to a previous life. Not forbidden. Not denounced. Outgrown, in the way a thing is outgrown when it has been replaced by something that does what it was doing.
I am telling you this near the top of the chapter rather than letting you find it out in a year from somebody less careful, because a book that manages you is worth nothing, and because you would have found out.
And now the part that is actually on the bill
Having said that, look at what is and is not being asked of you, now, as the price of starting.
Nothing is taken on a date. There is no point in the process where you are required to stop doing something, no renunciation, no ceremony of leaving, nothing you have to tell your mother. The change described above is one the material reports happening to people rather than one it imposes, and it reports it happening slowly and from the inside.
And you can start without it having happened. The material does not require you to have left anything before you begin. Nobody is at the door.
So the line item on the invoice reads: nothing now; possibly a change of taste later, on no timetable, which you would be the one to notice. That is not the clean nothing the job and the house produced, and it is not the second of those either. It is also not what you were braced for, which was an ultimatum.
The question the material actually asks about observance
There is one, and it is not do you do this but do you know what it is for.
It draws a line through the middle of every repeated practice — including, pointedly, its own — between doing a thing with understanding and doing it because it is done. The criticism is aimed at the second, and it is aimed at its own people at least as often as anywhere else.
That is a usable question rather than a verdict, and you can run it on your own observance without anybody's permission and without it being a loyalty test.
It is also not a trick. A reader braced for this will expect the question to be a device for getting them to conclude that their observance is empty. It is not, and plenty of people run it and find a good answer. What makes it worth running is that either answer is information — and most people have never once been asked.
The check
Pick one thing you do. One — the smallest and most ordinary, not the grandest.
Try to say, in two sentences, what it is for.
Not whether it is true. Not whether you believe it. What it is for — what it is supposed to do, to whom, and why it is done the way it is rather than some other way.
Three things happen, and the first is commoner than people expect.
Some people answer immediately and well, and are slightly surprised at how ready the answer was. That is worth knowing: you have more than you thought you had.
Some people find they can say what it is for, but that the answer is social — it is for being with the family, for the day having a shape, for your grandmother. That is a real answer and not a lesser one. Do not let anybody, including this book, talk you out of it.
And some people find there is nothing there at all, and that they have done the thing for thirty years without once being asked. If that is you, notice the feeling that arrives with the discovery. It is usually not guilt. It is usually relief, with something underneath it, and the something is worth more than the thirty years.
What this does not promise
It does not promise that your observance survives. It does not promise that it does not. It takes no position on whether what you do is true, and nothing in it is an argument against any religion.
What it removes is the ultimatum. Nobody is going to make you choose this week, or this year, and the version in your head where you have to decide before you are allowed to start is not how any of it works.
Two removed outright, two of them complicated, and one line item left. It is the one people are most embarrassed to raise and ask about most often — whether any of this is going to be any fun.
Questions
- Do I have to stop going to my temple, church or mosque?
Nothing is required of you at the start, nothing is taken on a date, and there is no ceremony of leaving. But the chapter declines to leave it there: the material's own view is that devotional practice is eventually left behind by people who go far into it, and it says so near the top rather than at the back. What is removed is the ultimatum, not the practice.
- Is there anything I have to believe or do first?
There is no entry rite. Nothing to sign, no declaration, no first act, and nothing required before you start.
- What does the tradition actually ask about religious practice?
Not do you do this but do you know what it is for — a question you can run on your own observance without anybody's permission. Either answer is information, and it is for being with my family is a real answer and not a lesser one.