You Do Not Have to LeaveChapter 10 of 146 min
Not waiting to be told you are all right
The third thing is the quietest and the hardest to see, and unlike the other two it does not feel like a request at all. It feels like being told that something perfectly normal about you is a problem, which is irritating, and the irritation is worth noticing because it is part of the subject.
You are asked to stop waiting to be told that you are all right.
Not to stop wanting it. That is not on offer and anybody promising it is selling something. To notice the waiting, which is continuous, which you have never counted, and which is costing more than you think.
What the waiting actually looks like
Not vanity. This is the mistake people make with this chapter — they look for vanity, do not find much, and conclude it is not about them.
It is much smaller and much more frequent than vanity.
It is checking whether the message was read. It is the half-second of scanning a face after you have said something. It is rereading a reply to see whether it was warm enough. It is noticing that somebody else was thanked and you were not, and then noticing that you noticed, and being slightly embarrassed. It is the particular flatness of having done something well with nobody there.
None of that is shameful and none of it makes you a vain person. It is simply the thing happening, many times a day, at a volume low enough that you have never once added it up.
What you were afraid of
That this is the chapter where it turns moralistic. Where a book that has been reasonable about your house and your dinner finally gets round to telling you that wanting to be liked is a flaw.
It is not, and I want to be exact about why.
Wanting recognition is not the thing being examined. What is being examined is where your assessment of yourself is currently kept — whether it lives with you or whether it is held, in small deposits, by about forty people who have no idea they are holding it and who are not reliable about returning it.
That is not a moral claim. It is a claim about storage, and the objection to the current arrangement is practical rather than ethical: the people holding it are busy, distracted, inconsistent, and occasionally unkind for reasons that have nothing to do with you.
What the material says, and the mechanism it gives
Two things, and the second is the one that makes this workable.
The first is that the alternative to the current arrangement is not modesty and not confidence. It is a specific thing the material calls self-respect, and it is careful to separate it from arrogance in the same breath: there is no arrogance in spirituality; instead of arrogance, there is self-respect. The two are not points on a scale with humility at one end. They are different arrangements.
The second is the mechanism, and it names the route in, precisely. The way onto the other one — the attractive, comfortable, thoroughly decorated alternative that the material calls a seat of thorns — is comparison. Its exact words for how the thought arrives are worth having:
You look at one another and think that you too should taste it. You think: So-and-so has experienced this, so why shouldn't I do the same?
That is not a description of vanity either. It is a description of an ordinary Tuesday, and of the sentence that runs under a great deal of ambition, resentment and tiredness without ever being said out loud.
And the material offers one test, which is the cleanest thing in this chapter: check what you want from the people around you. The other arrangement wants nothing from them. Not their agreement, not their approval, not their noticing.
Why this is the third request and not the first
Because it cannot be done by deciding to. You cannot stop waiting to be told you are all right by resolving to stop, any more than you can stop being thirsty by deciding not to drink.
What the material describes is not a suppression but a replacement — the two states occupy the same position, so the way out of one is to be in the other, not to fight the first. Which is why this chapter asks you only to notice, and why the two earlier requests come first: the fixed point and the half-second are both things you can simply do, and this one is not.
So the request in this chapter is smaller than the other two. It is to count.
The check
One week. Count, and change nothing.
Every time you check for a response, register it. Opened the thread to see if it had been answered. Looked at the face. Reread the reply. Wondered whether they had noticed. Checked the number.
Do not judge any individual instance — most of them are completely reasonable, and that is rather the point.
At the end of the week, do not look at the total, which will tell you nothing except that you are a person. Look at where they cluster.
They will not be spread evenly. They will be concentrated around one or two people, and usually around one particular kind of work — generally the work you are least sure about, which is sometimes the work you are best at.
That clustering is the finding, and it is information about where you are currently storing your assessment of yourself, held in one place, by one or two people, who do not know they have it.
What this does not promise
It does not promise that you will stop minding what people think, and if that is what you wanted, this is the wrong book and possibly the wrong species.
It does not promise that you will become less ambitious, and it is not a recommendation to stop seeking recognition at work, where recognition is also money.
And it does not promise anything about how long the replacement takes, because the material does not say and I am not going to fill that in.
What it removes, if the counting goes the way it usually goes, is the belief that this is costing you nothing.
That is the full invoice: five things kept, three things asked. Which leaves the three questions that come next from anybody who has read this far and is taking it seriously — why it fails for people who honestly try, what to do about the one person you cannot get past, and what people will say. And then the bill, in full.
Questions
- Is wanting recognition a character flaw?
No, and the chapter is exact about why not. What is examined is not the wanting but where your assessment of yourself is currently kept — with you, or held in small deposits by about forty people who do not know they have it and are not reliable about returning it. That is a claim about storage rather than about morals.
- What does waiting for approval actually look like?
Much smaller and more frequent than vanity: checking whether the message was read, scanning a face after you have said something, rereading a reply to see whether it was warm enough, noticing somebody else was thanked. None of it is shameful; it has simply never been added up.
- How do I know if this applies to me?
Count for a week and change nothing, then look at where the marks cluster rather than at the total. They will concentrate around one or two people and one kind of work — usually the work you are least sure about, which is sometimes the work you are best at.