You Do Not Have to Leave
For somebody who has decided this is not for people like them
Free to read, in full, here. Fourteen chapters in four parts, about an hour and a half, and the page at the back is the apparatus rather than more book.
Somebody asks it in almost exactly these words, usually fondly, usually of somebody they love: if we all become spiritual, who is going to pay the bills?
It sounds like a joke and it is not one. It is the sharpest question in this whole subject, and it is not an argument about God. It is an argument about arrangements, and arrangements can be checked.
Think about the pictures you have been shown. The monk has no mortgage. The person on the retreat is not on call. The teacher giving the talk about non-attachment is housed and fed by an institution that exists so the talk can be given. None of it is concealed. It is simply never said in the same breath as the advice.
So you did what anybody does with an offer whose price exceeds what it is worth to them. You said it was not really for people like you, and you thought about something else. That is not a verdict about truth. It is a judgement about price — and this book’s claim is that the quotation was wrong.
Three of the five things you were braced to give up come off the bill outright. Two do not, and those chapters say so on their own pages rather than letting you find out in a year from somebody less careful. Then three chapters for what is actually asked, and the list does not get longer afterwards. And then the bill, in full, in the last chapter, with nothing moved into the small print.
Part One · The picture in the way
- Not for people like meHere is a sentence you have either said or thought, and probably said. It's not really for people like me.
- Who pays the billsThis chapter does not answer anything. It is the case against the rest of the book, put as well as I can put it, and it is put here rather than at the end…
Part Two · The things you keep
- The jobThe last chapter said that for this book to survive, three things would have to hold, and that the first was that nothing gets given up.
- The house, and what is in itYou keep the house. You keep what is in it, including the things you would be slightly embarrassed to itemise, and including the next thing you buy.
- The bodyThis is the chapter where the honest answer is not a clean nothing, and I would rather say so in the first line than be caught at it in the fourth.
- The temple, if you have oneWhat follows is not what I expected to find when I went looking, and I have left it as it came back rather than as it was meant to come back.
- The pleasureNobody asks this one out loud, and everybody wants to know. Is any of this going to be any fun? Or more precisely, and more honestly: is the plan that I…
Part Three · The things you are asked for instead
- A fixed hourHere is the other half of the invoice. Three things, three chapters, and the list does not get longer after chapter ten.
- Being wrong in front of someoneThe second of the three costs nothing, takes no time, requires no equipment and cannot be scheduled.
- Not waiting to be told you are all rightThe third thing is the quietest and the hardest to see, and unlike the other two it does not feel like a request at all.
Part Four · What you will meet
- I tried it and nothing happenedSomebody gave you a sentence. It was a good sentence. It was about being enough, or being at peace, or being the one who decides what happens next in your…
- Do I have to forgive themIf somebody is hurting you now, this chapter is not for you, and nothing in this book asks you to stay where you are. Not for a while, not until…
- What people will thinkThis is the smallest objection in the book and it stops more people than any of the others, which is worth saying out loud because nobody admits to it.
- What it costsThirteen chapters spent mostly on what this does not cost is a sales technique unless there is a bill at the end, so here it is, itemised, with nothing moved…
At the back
Questions
- Do I have to give anything up?
Five things are looked at, one chapter each: the job, the house and what is in it, the body, your observance if you have one, and your pleasures. Three come off the bill outright. Two do not come off cleanly, and those two chapters say so on their own pages rather than letting you find out later from somebody less careful.
- If I become spiritual, who pays the bills?
You do, at the same job, to the same standard. Chapter two gives that question a whole chapter before a word of answer, because it is the strongest thing a sceptical reader has. The short version: nothing in the book relieves you of a single practical responsibility, and the one thing it claims about your work is that the output does not depend on the anxiety.
- How much time does it take?
A fixed point in the day that the day does not get to move, and the book is explicit that the length is nearly beside the point and the fixing is nearly everything. It refuses the large figures that circulate in this area — a third of the day is a real number real people have been given — on the grounds that a practice which begins by requiring a life you do not have is not a practice but a filter.
- What is actually being asked, then?
Three things, and the list does not get longer. A fixed point in the day. A half-second after somebody corrects you, which is the one most people would rather swap for the hour. And an honest count of where you have been keeping your sense of whether you are all right. The last chapter prices all three, in full, with nothing moved into the small print.
- Do I have to stop going to my temple, or my church?
No, and the book declines to leave it there. Nothing is required of you at the start, there is no entry rite and nothing is taken on a date. But the material's own view is that devotional practice is eventually left behind by people who go far into it, and chapter six says that near its top rather than at the back. What is removed is the ultimatum, not the practice.
- Do I have to be religious, or believe something first?
No. There is no entry rite, nothing to sign and no first act, and the book offers no proof of any claim about the universe. It is an audit of a price list rather than an argument for a belief, and it would be as useful to somebody who thinks the whole metaphysical apparatus is a fairy story.
- I tried something like this before and nothing happened.
That is chapter eleven, and it is the chapter to read first if it is the reason you stopped. Its claim is that you were given the wrong instruction: you were handed a sentence and told to repeat it until it became true, and repetition is not the mechanism. A sentence you have not found to be true cannot hold anything up, and it was not load-bearing on the first morning either.