You Do Not Have to LeaveChapter 5 of 146 min
The body
This is the chapter where the honest answer is not a clean nothing, and I would rather say so in the first line than be caught at it in the fourth.
The job and the house came off the bill completely. This one comes off it for now, which is a different thing, and a reader who has been told two straightforward truths is owed the complicated one in the same voice.
The list
A list, and you have seen versions of it your whole life.
Vegetarian, probably vegan. Up at four. No alcohol. No coffee. Fasting of some kind, on days you would have to look up. Thin, pale, faintly unwell-looking, and quietly pleased about it. A person who has made their body into a subject.
And beneath the list, the thing that actually puts people off: the suspicion that the body is regarded as the enemy. That whatever this is, it holds your appetite in contempt, considers your pleasure in a good dinner to be a weakness, and would — if you went far enough in — have you treating hunger as a moral event.
Where that came from, and the part that is true
It came from somewhere accurate, which is why it is sticky.
Mortification is real. There are traditions, serious ones, in which the body is disciplined hard and the discipline is the point. If that is your picture, it is a picture of something that exists.
And this tradition does have dietary practice. I am not going to be clever about this. Food prepared and eaten in a particular way is treated as a genuine support, and anybody who goes some distance into this will meet that, and will meet people for whom it matters a great deal. A book that said nothing is asked about the body and let you find that out later from somebody else would have lied to you on page one of this chapter.
So here is the accurate version. Nothing about the body is asked of you at the beginning. There is no entry requirement, no diet to adopt before you are allowed to start, and nobody is standing at the door checking. There are practices, they come later, they come from people rather than from enforcement, and you can take them or leave them for as long as you like. What there is not, at any stage, is the thing you were actually afraid of — contempt for the body as such.
What is actually being asked
The source material's own picture of the relationship is not war and it is not indulgence. It is driving.
The thing that drives, and the thing being driven. And the whole of the instruction is that the driver drives. Not that the vehicle is bad, not that it should be starved or punished or resented, but that it is not the one deciding where to go.
Set beside the mortification picture, that is almost the opposite arrangement. A person at war with their body is extremely interested in their body. The driver is not — the driver is interested in the destination and uses the vehicle to get there, and would think it odd to spend the journey either worshipping or fighting the car.
And the instruction that follows from it is startlingly relaxed. One passage comes down to this: eat, drink, and do not forget. The eating and drinking are not the problem and are not asked about. The forgetting is the subject.
Another passage says the same thing from the other end: held that way, the senses stay with you rather than running the day; held the other way, you spend the day being driven by whichever one spoke loudest.
The specific misconception, named
It is worth saying plainly because it circulates widely and some of it circulates inside this sort of tradition, said by people who should know better.
Neglecting your body is not evidence of anything. Not sleeping, not eating properly, not going to the doctor, running yourself into the ground in the service of something worthwhile — none of that is a spiritual credential, and treating it as one is a straightforward misreading. The vehicle is maintained because it is being used.
If you have met somebody who seemed to think otherwise, you met somebody who had got it wrong, and you were right to find it unattractive.
The check
One week. Change nothing — and I mean that, because the instinct on reading this chapter is to improve your diet, and improving your diet would ruin the measurement.
Notice each time you eat, drink or reach for something in order to change how you feel.
Not because you were hungry. Not because it was dinner time, or because it was good, or because somebody put it in front of you. Because something had happened, or was about to, or had not happened yet, and the fastest available way to alter the inside of your head was to put something into your mouth or your hand.
Count them. Do not stop any of them.
Most people find two things. The number is higher than they expected, and — this is the useful part — it clusters. It is not spread evenly through the week. It sits in particular hours, after particular kinds of day, and usually after a particular kind of conversation.
That clustering is the finding. It tells you what the eating is standing in for, which is not information about your diet at all.
And there is a second thing in that week which you will not have been counting, because nothing asked you to.
Most of what you ate was neutral. You were hungry, or it was one o'clock, or somebody put it in front of you, and nothing about the inside of your head was involved at all. That is the larger part of almost everybody's week, and it is the control the count is being read against.
It is worth noticing once, deliberately, because it is the only demonstration in this chapter of the thing the chapter is actually describing — and you are not being asked to build it. You have it already, most of the time, every day, and you have simply never had occasion to look at it.
What this does not promise
It does not promise that you will eat better, feel better, sleep better or live longer. It makes no health claim of any kind, and I want to be explicit about that, because this is exactly the place where books like this one start making them and the claims are almost always unfalsifiable and sometimes cruel.
Nothing in this book says your health is in your hands. It is not, entirely, and anybody who tells a sick person otherwise has told them that being ill was a failure of attention.
What this chapter removes is the entry requirement you invented. You do not have to change what you eat to begin. There is no door you are being kept outside.
The next one is more delicate still, and in the opposite direction. Not what you would have to give up, but what you would have to take on — and for a reader who already has somewhere they go and something they do there, the question is whether any of that survives.
Questions
- Do I have to become vegetarian or change my diet?
Not to begin, and the chapter is careful not to pretend more than that. Nothing about the body is asked at the start: no entry requirement, no diet to adopt first, nobody at the door. There are dietary practices further in, they are real, and you can take or leave them for as long as you like.
- Does spirituality treat the body as an enemy?
No, and the chapter says the inversion plainly: neglecting your body is not evidence of anything. The material's own picture is driving — the body is the vehicle and you are the one driving — which is almost the opposite of mortification, because a person at war with their body is extremely interested in their body.
- Will this improve my health?
The chapter makes no health claim of any kind and says why: nothing in the book says your health is in your hands, because read backwards that tells everyone who did not recover that being ill was a failure of attention.