Sella Yaso
→

You Do Not Have to LeaveChapter 1 of 145 min

Not for people like me

Here is a sentence you have either said or thought, and probably said.

It's not really for people like me.

It gets said kindly. It is not a sneer and it is not an argument, and the person saying it is usually being careful to leave room for whoever it is for. It has the shape of a polite withdrawal from something perfectly respectable that happens to belong to somebody else.

And it is the most interesting sentence in this entire subject, because of what it is not.


Nobody says the obvious thing

If you thought it was false, you would say so.

People do say so about other things, readily and at length. Ask them about homeopathy, or astrology, or a politician's promise, and they will tell you it is nonsense and give reasons. The reasons may be good or bad, but the objection is on the table and it can be argued with.

That almost never happens here. Press somebody on not for people like me and you very rarely arrive at and I think the whole thing is untrue. You arrive somewhere else entirely — at time, at temperament, at circumstances, at what their life is actually like on a Wednesday.

It is not a verdict about truth. It is a judgement about fit. And fit is a judgement about price.


The three things it usually means

Not for people this busy. The commonest, and the most honest. You have not formed a view on the metaphysics because you have not had a spare half-hour in which to form one. The offer has always arrived addressed to somebody with margin in their week, and you have none.

Not for people like me, temperamentally. You are too impatient for it, or too sceptical, or too fond of your own anger, or too interested in money, or too worldly in a way you are not entirely sorry about. You have a picture of the sort of person who does this, and it is not a picture of you, and you do not especially want it to be.

Not for people in my position. Somebody has to run this household, this business, this ward, this family. The people in the picture are not running anything. Somebody is running things for them.

All three are about cost. None of them is about whether any of it is so.


Which means you have already been quoted a price

Somewhere along the line you were given a quotation, probably without noticing, and you declined it. That is a perfectly rational thing to have done. You did what anybody does with an offer whose price exceeds what it is worth to them: you said no and thought about something else.

The claim of this book is that the quotation was wrong.

Not that the price is worth paying — that is a different argument and a weaker one. That the figure you were given is not the figure. That the thing you declined is not the thing that was for sale, and that the version in your head was assembled out of monks, retreats, people who went odd, and advertisements for weekends you could not have afforded or attended.

So this is not a book that will try to persuade you of anything. It offers no proof of any claim about the universe, asks you to accept nothing on trust, and would be exactly as useful to somebody who thinks the whole metaphysical apparatus is a fairy story. It is an audit of an invoice.


What the audit consists of

Part Two goes through the five things you believe you would have to give up, one each: the job, the house and what is in it, the body, the temple if you have one, and the pleasure. Five chapters, five line items, and in each case the question is the same — is this actually on the bill, or did you put it there?

Part Three is the other half, and it is shorter, because the list is shorter. Three things are actually asked for. Not twelve, not a lifestyle, not a change of circumstances first. Three, and they are named, and one of them you will not like.

Part Four is why it fails for people who try, what to do about the hardest request in it, what other people will say, and then the bill — what this does cost, in full, with nothing moved into the small print.


And a warning, which belongs here rather than at the end

The price is not zero. If it were, this book would be a sales brochure and you would be right to put it down.

There is a real cost and it is set out in the last chapter rather than hinted at throughout, so that you can turn to it now if you would rather see the bill before the pitch. Some readers should. If you are the sort of person who would resent being walked through eleven reassurances before being told the figure, chapter fourteen is where it is, and the book will survive being read backwards.

What I will say here is that the cost is not the one you have been assuming, and it is not payable in the currency you were braced for. It is not money. It is not hours, in any quantity that would show up in your week. It is not your job, your house, your family or your temperament.

It is, roughly, three inconveniences, and the third of them is genuinely unpleasant.


Before any of that

There is one more thing to do before the audit starts, and it has to be done properly or the rest of the book is a conjuring trick.

The objection has to be put at full strength. Not summarised, not softened, and not phrased by somebody who is about to knock it down — put as well as the person holding it could put it, and then left standing for a chapter, because an objection that gets answered the moment it is raised has been handled rather than heard.

That is the next chapter, and it is the strongest thing in the book that is not on my side.


It begins with a question somebody asks in almost exactly these words, usually fondly, usually of somebody they love: if we all become spiritual, who is going to pay the bills?

← All chapters

Questions

Why do people say spirituality is not for them?

Almost never because they think it is false. Press anybody on it's not really for people like me and you very rarely arrive at and I think the whole thing is untrue — you arrive at time, at temperament, at what their week is actually like. It is not a verdict about truth. It is a judgement about fit, and fit is a judgement about price.

What does "not for people like me" actually mean?

Usually one of three things: not for people this busy, not for people of my temperament, or not for people in my position — somebody has to run this household. All three are about cost. None of them is about whether any of it is so.

Does this book try to convert anybody?

No. It offers no proof of any claim about the universe, asks you to accept nothing on trust, and would be exactly as useful to somebody who thinks the whole metaphysical apparatus is a fairy story. It is an audit of an invoice, not an argument for a belief.