Sella Yaso
←→

You Do Not Have to LeaveChapter 7 of 146 min

The pleasure

Nobody asks this one out loud, and everybody wants to know.

Is any of this going to be any fun? Or more precisely, and more honestly: is the plan that I stop enjoying things? The wine, the food, the programme you watch that you would not defend in company, the shopping, the holiday, the thing you look forward to at about four in the afternoon.

You have never asked because the question sounds adolescent next to the grandeur of the subject. It is not adolescent. It is the right question, and the reason it is the right question is that a life is mostly made of ordinary afternoons.


What you actually suspect

Not asceticism exactly — that was two chapters ago, with the body. Something flatter and more plausible.

You suspect that what is on offer is a mild, well-lit, slightly boring version of your life. That the sharp pleasures come off, and what is left is herbal tea and early nights and a sort of pleasantness. Not suffering. Just less.

And you have noticed that nobody in this area ever quite denies it. They say things about higher pleasures and deeper satisfactions, which is precisely what somebody would say if the answer were yes.


Where that came from

From the word renunciation, which has leaked out of the traditions that actually mean it and now colours everything in the vicinity.

And from a real observation: people who get seriously into something like this often do drop things. You have seen it. The drinking stops, or the spending slows, or they lose interest in something they used to be keen on. So the fear is not invented. The question is what the causal story is — whether the thing removed the pleasure, or whether the pleasure fell away because it was doing a job that no longer needed doing.

That distinction is the whole chapter.


What is actually being asked

Not abstinence. Not moderation either, which is the answer you were expecting and is a different and duller book.

The material's subject is not enjoyment at all. It is a specific state, and it describes it with unusual precision: people who constantly have all temporary attainments and are never content — who always want to attain something or other, and whose running commentary is I want this, I want that.

Read that carefully, because it does not say what people assume it says.

It is not a complaint about having things. The people described in that passage have them. It is a description of a particular relationship with wanting, in which the wanting does not stop when it is satisfied, because satisfaction was never what it was for.

So the thing under examination is not your pleasure. It is your dependence. Those are not the same and the difference is testable, which is the next section.


The difference, and how to tell

Here is the plain version.

A pleasure is something that makes a good hour better. A dependence is something that makes an ordinary hour bearable, and the proof is what happens when it is not available.

You already run this distinction confidently in other people's lives. You know the difference between a friend who enjoys a drink and a friend who needs one, and you did not work it out from the quantity. You worked it out from watching what happened on the evening there was not one.

The material's claim is not that the first kind is suspect. It is that the second kind is expensive — that it costs attention continuously, that it has to be fed on a schedule, and that the feeding is mistaken by the person doing it for enjoyment, which is why it never satisfies.

Nothing about this requires you to give anything up. It requires you to know which kind you are holding.


The check, and it takes an hour

This one is the cleanest in the book and it takes an hour.

Take one thing you do every day that you enjoy. Not a vice, not something you already feel bad about — that would contaminate the measurement with guilt. Something ordinary and defensible. The evening drink, the scroll, the programme, the four o'clock chocolate, the hour of the game.

Skip it once. Not for a week. Once, on an ordinary day, chosen in advance, and not announced to anybody as a fast or a test, because announcing it turns it into a performance and performances have their own rewards.

Then note, not whether you managed — you will manage — but what the hour was like.

There are two results and they are easy to tell apart.

Either the hour was slightly duller and you thought about it twice and got on with the evening. In which case it is a pleasure, there is nothing to discuss, and this chapter does not apply to you.

Or the hour was loud. You thought about it more than twice. You negotiated. You found a reason why today was not a representative day. You were irritable with somebody who had not done anything.

That second result is not a moral failure and it is not a diagnosis of anything. It is one piece of information about one habit, gathered in one evening, and the only thing it tells you is that the thing was doing a job you had not known it was doing.


What this does not promise

It does not promise that you will enjoy things more, which is the claim this kind of book usually makes here and cannot support. It does not tell you to drink less, spend less or watch less, and there is no list in this book of things to give up — not in this chapter and not later.

And it does not promise that nothing falls away. Some things probably do, over long periods, for the reason given above. What it denies is the order of events you were imagining, in which you give things up first, as the entry fee, and the benefit comes afterwards as a reward for having suffered.

That is not the order. Nothing is surrendered in advance. If something goes, it goes the way interest goes — quietly, later, and noticed after the fact.


That is the whole of what you keep: the job, the house and what is in it, the body, your observance if you have one, and your pleasures. Five line items, three removed outright and two honestly complicated. Which leaves the other half of the invoice, and it is time I showed you it. There are three things actually being asked for, they are named in the next three chapters, and the list does not get longer afterwards.

← All chapters

Questions

Will I have to stop enjoying things?

The subject is not enjoyment and not moderation either. It is a specific state the material describes precisely: people who constantly have all temporary attainments and are never content, whose running commentary is I want this, I want that. Note that the people described already have the things.

What is the difference between a pleasure and a dependence?

A pleasure makes a good hour better. A dependence makes an ordinary hour bearable, and the proof is what happens on the evening it is not available. You already run this distinction confidently about other people.

Do I have to give things up first, as a kind of entry fee?

No, and the chapter denies that order of events specifically. Nothing is surrendered in advance. If something falls away it goes the way interest goes — quietly, later, and noticed after the fact.