You Do Not Have to LeaveChapter 12 of 147 min
Do I have to forgive them
If somebody is hurting you now, this chapter is not for you, and nothing in this book asks you to stay where you are. Not for a while, not until something improves, not in a better frame of mind. That sentence is first because it is the only one in the chapter that cannot wait.
What follows is about something that is over — months or years over — and is still being carried.
The question, as it is actually held
You have read eleven chapters and most of it has been smaller than you were quoted. And somewhere in the back of all of it there has been one person, and one thing they did, and a flat certainty that whatever this turns out to be, it is going to come round to them eventually and ask you to let it go.
You have been waiting for that. Some readers have been waiting for it since chapter one, with their guard up, because they have been handed this before — usually by somebody who did not know what had happened, in a warm voice, with a word like healing in the sentence.
So let me do this plainly and in order, and name what is asked and what is not, and then say what the material refuses to promise, which is the part that will matter most to you.
Four things that are not being asked
Not that you see them. Nothing here involves contact, a conversation, a meeting, a message, or being in the same room. Reconciliation is a separate thing with separate risks and it is not this.
Not that you say it was all right. Nothing is withdrawn, excused, reinterpreted or downgraded. The material is firmer about this than most readers expect — one passage says of a wrong that the mark is not removed, that the record does not come back clean. What happened is not being rewritten.
Not that you feel warm. This is the one that traps people, because they try to produce a feeling, cannot, and conclude they have failed at something. The definition the material gives is not a feeling at all, which I will come to.
And not on a schedule. No interval is specified, nothing is late, and the idea that a person should have got past something by now is not in the material. It belongs to the people around you, who find the subject uncomfortable.
What the material actually says
It is more direct than people expect, and it is addressed to exactly the situation you are in — not to people with a grievance, but to people who were harmed.
The instruction is given outright: those with a harmful attitude are to be met with a benevolent one, that is, you have to forgive them. So anybody who tells you this tradition does not teach forgiveness of others is simply wrong, and it is worth knowing that.
Then it defines the word, and the definition is the useful part:
Forgiveness means to give them the blessings of good wishes, to give them co-operation.
That is a description of actions, not of an emotion. Nothing in it requires you to feel anything in particular about this person, which is the single most freeing thing in the chapter, because feeling is the thing you cannot command and have probably been failing at for years.
And the sentence that makes it safe
Here is the fence, and it is the material's own rather than mine, which matters because it means this is not a kindness I have added to make the chapter survivable.
You may not be able to transform them, but you can forgive them.
Read what that gives up. It does not promise they change. It does not suggest that your good wishes will reach them, soften them, bring an apology, or produce the conversation you have rehearsed. It explicitly declines all of that in the same breath as giving the instruction.
That matters more than anything else in this chapter, because the version of this teaching that does harm is always the version with a promise attached — do this and they will come round — which sets a person up to do something difficult, get nothing, and conclude they did it wrong.
You may not be able to transform them. That is said first.
Where it starts, and it is not with them
One more thing, and it is consistent across the material: the self-directed act comes first.
The ordering is not decorative and it is not a softening. Mercy towards yourself is named as the precondition rather than the reward — and the material is careful to distinguish it from self-pity, which is a different thing that feels similar from inside.
Which means that if you can do nothing else in this chapter, the part addressed to you is the part to do, and the part addressed to them can wait indefinitely. It is not a sequence you are failing to complete. It is a sequence that starts where you are.
What this book does not know
I would rather state a gap than paper one over, and there is a real one here.
The material I have read does not address sustained abuse. Not beating, not rape, not years of it. There are passages about harm, and about accounts and consequences, and none of them is written about that, in either direction — neither to explain it nor to tell somebody what it meant.
Other people will tell you what it meant. Some of them will say something that sounds like an explanation and amounts to telling you that you set it in motion. That is not in the source material and this book will not bridge the gap to it. If it reaches you with this book's name anywhere near it, it did not come from here.
So: for that reader, this chapter offers the first sentence of it and nothing else, and does not pretend to more.
The check, and some readers should skip it
Skip it if the subject is still sharp. That is not a failure of nerve; it is the right reading of your own state, and the material's own position is that a dose given to somebody not in a condition to take it makes things worse rather than better.
For everybody else, it is one sentence, said once, in your head, about one person.
May it go well for them.
That is all. Do not examine whether you meant it — you probably did not, the first time, and meaning it is not the entry condition. Do not repeat it daily, which would make it the thing chapter eleven described. Say it once and then notice, over the following day or two, what turns up afterwards.
What usually turns up is not peace. It is an argument — a list of reasons why they do not deserve it, which is a list you could have produced at any point and which is probably accurate.
The list is the finding. Not because it is wrong, but because of how fast it arrived, and because it tells you how much of the thing you are carrying is being actively maintained rather than simply remembered.
What this does not promise
It does not promise lightness. The join between forgiving somebody else and feeling lighter is not one I can show you in the material, and I am not going to assert it because it is what you would want to hear.
It does not promise resolution, an apology, or that the person becomes someone you could stand to see.
And it does not promise that the thing stops mattering. It will matter. The question this chapter raises is only whether all of the weight currently on it is the weight of what happened, or whether some of it is the weight of keeping the case open.
One thing left before the bill, and it is the smallest of the objections and the most commonly acted on: what people will say, and whether you are about to become the person in your family that everybody manages around.
Questions
- Do I have to forgive someone who hurt me?
If somebody is hurting you now, nothing in this book asks you to stay where you are — that is the chapter's first sentence and it comes before anything else. For harm that is over, the instruction is given outright in the material and is addressed to people who were harmed rather than to people with a grievance.
- Does forgiving mean seeing them again, or saying it was all right?
Neither. Not contact, not reconciliation, nothing withdrawn or excused — the material is firmer than most readers expect that the mark is not removed and the record does not come back clean. And not on a schedule: no interval is specified and nothing is late.
- What if I cannot make myself feel forgiving?
You are not asked to. The definition given is a description of actions, not of an emotion — good wishes and co-operation — which is the single most freeing thing in the chapter, because feeling is the thing you cannot command.
- Will forgiving them make them change?
No, and the material declines to promise it in the same breath as giving the instruction: you may not be able to transform them, but you can forgive them. That matters, because the version of this teaching that does harm is always the version with a promise attached.