You Do Not Have to LeaveChapter 4 of 145 min
The house, and what is in it
You keep the house.
You keep what is in it, including the things you would be slightly embarrassed to itemise, and including the next thing you buy. Nothing here involves a reduction, a clear-out, a simpler life, or a conversation with your family about what you are going to stop replacing.
This is the shortest chapter in Part Two, and it is short on purpose. There is a very large and very good argument underneath it, and an entry book is not the place for the large version. What you need in order to keep reading is the small version, and the small version is one word.
Two fears, and the second is the real one
Two things, and they are different.
The first is the obvious one — that you would be asked to give things away, live more plainly, and feel permanently slightly wrong about the kitchen.
The second is less obvious and it is the one doing the work. You already half-agree with the accusation. Some part of you suspects you have too much, or wants too much, or thinks about it too often, and you have arranged not to look at that directly. A book that proposes to open the subject is a book that proposes to make you uncomfortable about something you have successfully managed not to be uncomfortable about for years.
So the resistance here is not really about losing the house. It is about being made to feel like somebody who has one.
Where that came from
The same place as everything else in Part Two. The visible examples are people who divested, and divestment is a real and coherent practice with a long history, and it does ask exactly what you are afraid of.
And then there is the second-hand version, which is worse: the vague modern sense that wanting things is a bit shabby, held by people who have plenty and deployed mostly against people who have less. You have met that and you were right to dislike it.
What is actually being asked
Not less. Differently held.
The source material puts it in one word, and the word is not things. It is mine.
It describes the alternative as holding what you have the way a trustee holds it — using it completely, deciding about it, being accountable for it, and not owning it — and then it says the thing that makes this a chapter rather than a slogan: a trustee is one who does not have any consciousness of "mine". The same passage takes it further than most readers will expect on a first pass: when the consciousness of "mine" finishes, the attachment finishes with it. The attachment was never to the object. It was to the word.
Another, from a different decade, says it with the alternative attached. Living at home with your family, consider yourself a trustee rather than a householder — and a householder is defined not as somebody with a house but as somebody carrying all your past and future burdens on your head.
Nothing in either passage is about quantity. You are not told how much to have. You are told what it costs to hold it the first way, and the cost is not moral. It is weight.
Why this chapter stops here
Because the thing I have just described is an enormous subject, and there is a point past which an entry book is making a worse version of an argument that deserves its own hundred pages.
What you need for the purposes of this book is the line item. The house is not on the bill. Nothing in Part Three asks you to own less, want less, or justify anything you have. If you later want the long version of why the word mine is the expensive part, it is available and it is worth having, and it is not here.
The check
This one is unpleasant in a small way and takes about four seconds, and it will happen on its own within a fortnight.
Something of yours will get damaged. Not destroyed — chipped, scratched, marked, left out in the rain, broken by somebody who did not mean it, probably somebody you live with.
Note the size of your reaction, and then ask what it was proportionate to.
Was it proportionate to the damage — to the actual cost of repair or replacement, in money and inconvenience, which you could estimate in a moment if asked?
Or was it proportionate to something else: that it was yours, that it was the good one, that you had been careful with it, that you had asked them to be.
Most people, honestly watched, find a gap between the two sizes. That gap is the whole subject of this chapter, measured in your own house, with no theory required. It is also the cheapest demonstration available that the weight is not coming from the object, since the object's actual cost was the smaller number.
What this does not promise
It does not promise that you will stop minding. It does not tell you what to own or what to want, and it will not resolve the suspicion you have about your own appetites, which is a real question and is chapter seven's, not this one's.
What it removes is the line item. You were braced to be asked for the house, and nobody asked.
Two down, and both of them cheaper than you had priced them. The third is the one where I am going to have to be more careful with you, because it is the one where the honest answer is not a clean "nothing" — and pretending otherwise would cost this book the only thing it has, which is that it has not yet told you anything that is not so.
Questions
- Do I have to give away my possessions?
No. You keep the house and what is in it, including the next thing you buy. Not less — differently held. The word the material puts the weight on is not things: it is mine, and it says that when the consciousness of mine finishes, the attachment goes with it.
- Why does it hurt so much when something of mine gets damaged?
The chapter gives a four-second test for exactly this. When something of yours is chipped or marked, note the size of your reaction and ask what it was proportionate to — the actual cost of repair, or the fact that it was yours. Most people find a gap, and the gap is the subject.